Viglinks

Showing posts with label doctrine of necessity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label doctrine of necessity. Show all posts

Monday, November 23, 2015

Understanding Doctrine of Necessity and the Pakistan Connection

What is " Doctrine of Necessity" and its Sordid Connection with Pakistan

The Doctrine of necessity is an ancient law, but is rarely used except in Pakistan where it has been used to justify martial law and the sordid hanging of Bhutto, prime minister of pakistan

Defination


“Doctrinne of necessity” is a legal term. This is a term used in constitutional law and is as old as history. What does it mean? It means that a government can resort to extra constitutional authority in case there is a breakdown in law and order. The purpose is to restore order in a situation when anarchy rules. The Romans used this doctrine in the occupied lands. Later in the 13th century the doctrine was given a legal cover by the 
jurist Henry de Bracton (1210-68).

Theory of Blackstone and Henry Bracton


Henry Bracton was perhaps the first to give a proper legal frame work to this theory. He lived during the 13th century and was perhaps influenced by the conditions in England at that time.
The doctrine was further revised by William Blackstone (1773-68) an English Jurist. Both jurists had a common thread that this doctrine was a necessity in case there was a breakdown in law and order. The crucial point is “breakdown in law and order”. There is a related question as to who will decide this. The jurists did not amplify on this matter.
‘Doctrine of Necessity’ has never been used in England. But it has been used in Germany by Hitler and now in Pakistan. Pakistan is one nation that has repeatedly upheld changes in Pakistan’s political environment by military coups under this doctrine. This makes sad reading.

Doctrine of Necessity and Pakistan


The Doctrine of Necessity has been known for over 2000 years, but it has been rarely invoked in modern history. The state of Pakistan has however relied on this doctrine to justify military coups and judicial political hangings like of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto by the army general Zia ul Haq.
The first time this doctrine was used in Pakistan was in 1954. The events are now well known. The then Governor general of Pakistan Ghulam Mohammed dismissed the constituent assembly. He took this unconstitutional step as he felt that the assembly did not represent the people of Pakistan. It was a partisan step and an appeal against theGovernor General’s order was filed in the Sind High court. The President of the Constituent Assembly Maulvi Tamizzuddin was the man who filed the appeal.
It is on record that the Sind high court ruled in favor of the petition filed by Maulvi Tamizzuddin. The Governor Generalwent in appeal to the Chief Court of Pakistan (later the Supreme Court). The then Chief Justice Muhammed Munir seeing the wind blowing with army breathing down his neck ruled in favor of the Governor General. Justice Munir relied on the doctrine of necessity as enunciated in Roman law and further enunciated by Ivor Jennings. This was a sad day for Pakistan.

Last word



This decision of Justice Munir became a precedent and on a number of occasions the Supreme Court of Pakistan justified Military Coups. Thus military coups against elected governments by general Zia ul Haq and general Mushraff who overthrew the elected civilian governments were given legitimacy.
the supreme court of Pakistan also acquised in the hanging of Zulfikar Ali bhutto. Not something Pakistan should be proud off.

Thursday, August 27, 2015

"Doctrine of Necessity": Pernicious theory to Justify Military Dictatorship in Pakistan

Doctrine of Necessity was used to Justify Military Rule
Introduction

The doctrine of necessity is a legal term that seeks to justify an action carried out by extra constitutional authority to restore order. This doctrine is based on the writings of the jurist Henry de Bracton (1210-68) and later 

William Blackstone (1773-68) an English Jurist. Both jurists stated that an act to restore order could come under the purview of the ‘Doctrine of Necessity. This doctrine has never been used in England or for that matter in the Anglo Saxon world, but it has been liberally interpreted in Pakistan. Out of all the major nations of the world Pakistan is one nation that has repeatedly upheld changes in Pakistan’s political environment under this doctrine.

Pakistan

The first time this doctrine appeared on the scene in Pakistan was in 1954. At that time the Governor General of Pakistan Ghulam Mohammed dismissed the constituent assembly on the ground that the assembly did not represent the people of Pakistan. An appeal against theGovernor General's order was filed in the Sind High court by the President of the Constituent Assemby Maulvi Tamizzuddin.

The Sind high court ruled in favor of the petition filed by Maulvi Tamizzuddin. But in an appeal which was heard in the Chief Court of Pakistan (later designated as the Supreme Court), Justice Muhammed Munir set aside the verdict of the Sind High Court and ruled in favor of the Governor General. The court relied on the doctrine of necessity as enunciated in Roman law and articulated by Ivor Jennings which stated that the well being of the people was the supreme law.

This decision of Justice Munir was to have far reaching effect on Pakistan politics and on a number of occasions the Supreme Court of Pakistan justified Military Coups. The court justified the military coup by general Zia ul Haq which overthrew the elected civilian Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. This had a nefarious fall out and ultimately led to Bhutto being hanged as a common criminal for a crime for which no legal evidence was available. In the hanging of Bhuttothe Pakistan Supreme court which had earlier upheld the rule of Zia under the doctrine of necessity also acquiesced in the hanging of Bhutto.

Result

The judgment of Justice Munir thus had a deleterious effect on Pakistan politics. Later he expressed his regret that he had invoked the doctrine of necessity in 1954, but the judgment of Justice Munir continued to haunt Pakistan. In 1998 when General Pervez Mushraff in a coup overthrew the elected government of Nawab Sharif the Pakistan Supreme Court again justified the coup on the grounds of the law of necessity. The law of necessity thus became a convenient way out to justify military take over’s.

Future

The wheel has now turned full circle and the new Chief Justice of Pakistan Iftekar Choudhry in 2009 has come out with a far reaching observation. He has announced that the doctrine of necessity needs to be buried and never used in Pakistan. The million dollar question is , will it happen? I don't think so