Viglinks

Showing posts with label Cariappa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cariappa. Show all posts

Sunday, June 14, 2015

The Indian General Staff Has Let the Soldier Down

India must be one singular nation in the world where the armed forces are treated scurvily. This has its roots in history as all along the Congress party that came to power after independence had no comprehension of what military power means. In addition they were mortally scared of a Coup d'etat and thought the best way was to emasculate the army, deny them weaponry, down grade the officer class  and over all create a climate where the soldier is the last man to be given a benefit.

One expected this ethos to change with the defeat of the Congress and coming to power of the BJP and that self styled slogan maker of Ache Din  , Narendra Modi. But as we have seen there is no change and Congress or BJP  are two sides of the same coin.

The civilian leadership has always been apathetic to the man in uniform, but matters are not helped by a supine leadership of the armed forces, in particular the army chief also known as COAS. The army chief heads the most organized force in the country and yet surprisingly in all decisions either he is sidelined or has no say. This is indeed a surprise as even in pacifist nations like Burma the army calls the shots, but in India the army chief for all the bravado in photographs is a man who is just what he is, a photograph.

It all started with General Cariappa, who was beholden to Nehru to be made the army chief. He superseded Lieutenant General Kulwant Singh as Nehru ha d a pathy to Sikhs in general. He also feared that Kulwant  would stage a coup( though this was highly unlikely) . Cariappa set the ball rolling as far subservience is concerned and as he was beholden to Nehru  agreed for down gradation of the designation of Commander in Chief to Chief of Army Staff. This was the first step and down the years successive army chiefs have just come and gone.  We have had the ludicrous case of general Thapar accepting an order from a Joint secretary( Read Brig Dalvi's book" Himalayan Blunder").

Field marshal Manekshaw had a chance but he was swayed by the fact that he had won the war and did nothing. That was the time to insist on lateral induction of army men in the civil services but it never happened as  Sam Manekshaw was not a visionary.

Subsequently the service accepted downgradation of pension from 70% to 50% of pay drawn and I cannot fathom how this happened. Why did not the 3 service chiefs put their foot down? Over the years the army chiefs  have sat on the fence and looked at camera with a smile, but neglected to put pressure on the GOI. Look at general VK Singh, a BJP man now. He went to the Supreme Court asking for a review of his age so that  he could serve the army longer. but OROP and its enforcement never occurred to him. Some men can have no shame.

 Next we have teh case of General Dilbagh Singh. This man in an address to ex-servicemen announced that OROP  is sanctioned, but OROP has not come and the ex-servicemen are now agitating for OROP. The world is watching , but the ruling dispensation has no shame. When the words of the Army chief were not honored, the honorable course was to resign as a Kshatriya and warrior. The code of the warrior demands it, yet this man is still in the chair and is now using his offices to scuttle the agitation, by interceding on behalf of the BJP government..

Now OROP is not sanctioned and I doubt it will ever come in the classical concept and the army chief again has no say. This makes sad reading and I wonder when these generals go up and meet their alma maters, what they will have to say. Did they for a few crumbs of office forget the man in uniform who they had sworn to defend ? It's so sad. There are a some generals sitting and fasting. I appreciate this, but what happened when they were in service?
The rot started with him

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Musings on One rank One Pension and the Perfidy of Modi and the BJP



Recently at the Singapore club an interesting talk commenced with some officers of the Singapore air force, retired like me. The talk inevitably turned to the Indian armed forces. I was surprised as to how abreast the foreign officers were of the affairs in the Indian armed force, in particular the army. The gist of the conversation was that the Indian army was losing its cutting edge and in the years to come would be so demoralized that it will not or could not hold India together and the balkanization of India was inevitable.

This appeared to me a farfetched thought, but the fact is that the armed forces right from the time of Nehru has been downgraded at every step and their perks and privileges pruned at every opportunity. This is surprising as a country like India facing an insurgency in the Indian heartland led by Maoists and independence movements in the North east as well as calculated terrorism in Kashmir are a neglected lot. The government be it of Nehru or Modi have not grasped that if India is to stay united it is only due to the army.

Nehru had his reasons as he feared a military coup and thus let the finest fighting machine in India go to seed, culminating in a massive defeat with China. Indira Gandhi was the best as the armed forces gave her a name in history for ever with the cutting to size of Pakistan and creation of Bangladesh. I remember in 1984 on R Day she sanctioned free rations for officers as well. Unfortunately Modi has talked about sanction of OROP, the most contentious item in the list of demands of the services. He promised, but like Humpty Dumpty has had a great fall. He has changed his mind and now is silent as his cabinet ministers Jaitley and Parrikar go about dousing the flames in the hearts of the servicemen. To say they are misled by the bureaucracy is a misnomer, for no civil servant can oppose something, if the government wants to give. It happened during the time free rations were sanctioned and again if the Modi and the government want OROP, it can be a reality.

There is apathy in the BJP government towards the armed forces. I wonder how they are better off than the Congress and Nehru. A decision of 2 parliaments has been negated by Modi. I am afraid he is the man; if he wanted would Jaitley and Parrikar not acquiescence?

 A lot of blame must also go to our top brass, the army in particular, where successive chiefs for personal gain (maybe) have acquiesced with the government in demoting themselves and the soldiers under their command. If right from the time of Cariappa the armed forces commanders had put their foot down this state of affairs where the retired armed forces personnel are literally begging for OROP would never have happened. Coming to OROP, I am afraid that what we understand in the classical concept of OROP will not be sanctioned. I hope to god I am wrong, but 2 or 3 decades hence the Indian state will have to pay a heavy price for the antics of the political leaders from the time of Nehru to Narendra Modi.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

How the Armed Forces Top Brass allowed Officer cadre to be Downgraded


At the time when India became free in 1847, a Major was in protocol at par with a District Superintendent of Police. The downslide really commenced when General Cariappa was appointed the Army Chief in 1951. Cariappa for all his good qualities was in reality not the man to be the Cin C of a professional army. He really had no strategic sense and there is not even one paper or note by him to Nehru about a possible threat from China. Having become the Army Chief after superceding Lt Gen Kulwant Singh, he was beholden to Nehru and the first list of protocol was issued during his time. The downgradation of the service ranks started from that time. Cariappa did nothing to arrest this debasement and I am told he was just enjoying himself as Army Chief.
Subsequent Army Chiefs also failed to arrest the decline in parity of an officer of the Armed forces with their civil counterparts. This is hard to understand, as the Army Chief headed the only organized force in the country. One reason for the lack of initiative was the defeat at the hands of China in 1962. Along with Nehru, the service Chiefs were criminally negligent about the Northern border. Having lost the war because of their own lack of strategic vision, the civil authority loomed larger over them. The Chiefs of all 3 services failed to bring any pressure on the government.In fact the downslide continued till the armed forces were at the lowest rung of the ladder.
A major blame for this must again go to the service Chiefs. in 1983/84 when Venkatraman was the Raksha Mantri, he suggested the rank of Lt Colonel in 13 years. But I do recollect the service Chiefs themselves turned down this proposal on the plea that it will 'devalue' the ranks. This was a shortsighted approach as the civil services were rising to DIG rank in 16-18 years. Thus it was service chiefs who cut their own feet. In any case 25 years down the line this did happen. The top brass of the army are basically men of straw. One must wonder how much love they have for the rank and file. It is silly that a Army Chief could knock the door of the Supreme court on a case regarding his age , yet he never did approach the court for a legitimate demand of OROP. As things stand , one cannot have much hope on the top brass. They have let the armed forces down at every stage. They have failed to bring up points to the government. perhaps its the survival instinct that is paramount as the Chief having risen to a position would like to enjoy that perk of office. Why get into a spat with the government ?

Monday, December 12, 2011

The Role of the Indian General Staff in the Debacle Against China(1962) * 62


Indian soldiers  in Ladakh
 I am reminded of attending a seminar on Nehru and China, where a speaker castigated Nehru for not having strategic vision.   In my question answer session I raised a few points which the speaker agreed.
I pointed out that Nehru was indeed culpable of neglect of the Northern borders, but the Indian General staff is equally culpable in this matter. General Cariappa who took over as the first Indian Army Chief had no knowledge of the topography of the Northern border including Aksai Chin and NEFA (North East Frontier Agency) now called Arunachal Pradesh. It is on record that he never visited Aksai Chin nor did he alert the Government of India to any possible threat from China. No note or service paper was annotated by him on this matter to the Ministry of Defense (MOD) or to Nehru himself.  Cariappa himself had no explanation for it. This is one of the tragedies of Indian Army  history.
The IAF was no better as the Air staff projected a requirement of a force level of just 15 squadrons of in 1954. This was enough for Pakistan but took no account of the threat from China. Air Marshal Subroto Mukherjee, the then Chief of Air Staff  erred grievously in not anticipating a threat from China
This state of affair continued and army Chiefs like General Thimmaya and Thapar just had no comprehension of the Chinese threat. They sadly lacked strategic vision and just played along with Nehru’s policy, instead of advising him to beef the northern border and strengthen the IAF and the Army to counter China. This is a grave lapse in history and points to a complacency that is hard to explain. The armed forces had their strategy only to counter Pakistan. This shows that the man who led the Indian army was men without a strategic concept and thus lacked the hallmark of great soldiers.
It is fashionable to blame Nehru for the China debacle, but the role of the General Staff also must stand scrutiny. Only if these men who led the Indian army had shone some mettle and acumen, India would not have been in the sorry state of affairs it was, against the Chinese army in 1962.