Viglinks

Sunday, March 31, 2019

Predicant of the Indian army; led by pussy footed generals

The Author

Many interesting articles are doing the rounds about the treatment of the army by the MOD. But they are becoming something stale as repeatedly the same facts are presented by many writers mostly retired generals and there can be no solution. 
The difference between the MOD and MHA functioning is stark and the question remains what next? The generals don't raise an obvious point that the impasse can only be solved with the help of the COAS. True a tradition of 65 years of always saying"yes sir, three bags full" is hard to change but somebody has to bell the cat.
Why can't the COAS accompanied by the other two chiefs meet the PM and present their views and the consequences? 
Just talking to the DS  or writing a small note is not going to absolve the general staff of their responsibility to the nation and the men they command.  Nobody writes or suggests on these lines, why? Isint it time someone belled the cat?

Saturday, March 16, 2019

Why India cannot be a great power


Basically its lack of political will. One will recollect that in 1948 China did not even manufacture a bicycle while India was much advanced with steel plant, aircraft, and a car factory. China has gone ahead and even launched a spaceman in orbit while Indian are still twiddling their thumbs. China has copied most Russian planes and they are none the worse for it. India, unfortunately, did not build up its military-economic complex and talked of peace leaving India way behind in great power status. The situation is that India can not even sort out Pakistan which is 1/5th the size of India. Neglect of the military industry has serious ramifications as India is dependent on foreign suppliers for its planes and guns. it cannot fight a sustained war as it produces almost zero military equipment. How India reached this sorry state is because of the Indian political leadership. Now to catch up to China is almost like a pipe dream and in the bargain gone forever is great power status which rests on military-economic- industrial capability.

New Zealand: 49 Muslim worshipers shot dead

https://us.blastingpop.com/news/2019/03/new-zealand-49-muslim-worshipers-shot-dead-in-attacks-on-mosques-in-christchurch-002871085.html
This is the height of absurd Islamophobia. Who will catch the cat by its tail?

49 Muslim worshipers were shot dead during attacks on mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand. The country has previously been immune to this type of incident. The idyll is shattered as gunmen opened fire on a congregation of Muslim worshipers attending prayer sessions in a mosque. This was on Friday, a day considered holy by Muslims. The Sri Lanka cricket team on a tour of New Zealand had also visited the mosque before the shooting. CNN has reported that the death toll in the Christchurch mosque attacks has increased to 49 and police say one man has already been charged with murder in the wake of the terrorist attack.

Monday, February 11, 2019

dracula fun: Walt Disney's Aladdin to release on 24th May this ...

dracula fun: Walt Disney's Aladdin to release on 24th May this ...: Aladdin is a name that conjures up a magic world laced with fantasy. Its an endearing tale of a boy who finds a magic lamp and through it c...

Walt Disney's Aladdin to release on 24th May this year

Aladdin is a name that conjures up a magic world laced with fantasy. Its an endearing tale of a boy who finds a magic lamp and through it controls a genie. This latest film of Aladdin will have Will Smith in the role of a blue colored Genie. The film is slated for release on 24th May this year.


It's a bit longish yet for the film's release but fans are already worked up about it. It should be an entertaining film as the story of the magic lamp, the genie and the boy Aladdin are folklore and known to all in the world.
There is a lovely princess also who looks more of one from India and that will be a double delight. All credit to Disney for bringing this wonderful tale on the screen for all and sundry.

Thursday, February 7, 2019

General David Goldfein Chief of USAF flies the Indian light combat fighter Tejas



The US Airforce Chief flew the Indian made Tejas at Jodhpur air base in Rajasthan while on an official visit to India.

    The Tejas is a Mach 2 fighter -interceptor manufactured at Bangalore by Hindustan  Aeronautics. It was inducted into the Indian Air Force in 2016. The US general was the first foreign officer to have flown this plane and the flight approved by the PM.

US AF Chief General David L Goldfein in Tejas cockpit (Photo credit-screenshot youtube-IDRW channel)

Wednesday, January 9, 2019

"Doctrine of Necessity" and its Sordid Connection with Pakistan

What is " Doctrine of Necessity" and its Sordid Connection with Pakistan


Definition


“Doctrine of necessity” is a legal term. This is a term used in constitutional law and is as old as history. What does it mean? It means that a government can resort to extra-constitutional authority in case there is a breakdown in law and order. The purpose is to restore order in a situation when anarchy rules. The Romans used this doctrine in the occupied lands. Later in the 13th century, the doctrine was given legal cover by the jurist Henry de Bracton (1210-68).

Theory of Blackstone and Henry Bracton


Henry Bracton was perhaps the first to give a proper legal framework to this theory. He lived during the 13th century and was greatly influenced by the conditions in England at that time.

The doctrine was further revised by William Blackstone (1773-68) an English Jurist. Both jurists had a common thread that this doctrine was a necessity, in case there was a breakdown in law and order. The crucial point is “breakdown in law and order”. There is a related question as to who will decide this. The jurists did not amplify on this matter.
In the 20th century, the doctrine was extensively studied and commented upon by the English Jurist Sir Ivor Jennings( 1903-62)

‘Doctrine of Necessity’ has never been used in England. But it has been used in Germany by Hitler and now in Pakistan. Pakistan is one nation that has repeatedly upheld changes in Pakistan’s political environment by military coups under this doctrine. This makes sad reading.

The doctrine of Necessity and Pakistan



The Doctrine of Necessity has been known for over 2000 years, but it has been rarely invoked in modern history. The state of Pakistan has however relied on this doctrine to justify military coups and judicial political hangings like of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto by the army general Zia ul Haq.

The first time this doctrine was used in Pakistan was in 1954. The events are now well known. The then Governor-General of Pakistan Ghulam Mohammed dismissed the constituent assembly. He took this unconstitutional step as he felt that the assembly did not represent the people of Pakistan. It was a partisan step and an appeal against the Governor General’s order was filed in the Sind High court.

The President of the Constituent Assembly Maulvi Tamizzuddin was the man who filed the appeal. It is on record that the Sind High Court ruled in favor of the petition filed by Maulvi Tamizzuddin. The Governor-General went in appeal to the Chief Court of Pakistan (later the Supreme Court). The then Chief Justice Muhammed Munir seeing the wind blowing with the army breathing down his neck ruled in favor of the Governor-General. Justice Munir relied on the doctrine of necessity as enunciated in Roman law and further enunciated by Ivor Jennings. This was a sad day for Pakistan.

Last word


This decision of Justice Munir became a precedent and on a number of occasions, the Supreme Court of Pakistan justified Military Coups. Thus military coups against elected governments by General Zia ul Haq and general Mushraff who overthrew the elected civilian governments were given legitimacy.
The Supreme Court of Pakistan also consented to the hanging of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Not something Pakistan should be proud of.

in 2009, the wheel turned full circle and Chief Justice Choudhry of Pakistan in a landmark judgment declared Martial Law unconstitutional. This was after the exit of General Musharaff. I hope this ruling stands the test of time for the future.